Send us a suggestion!

Multiple SAR incidents in Birch Hollow

Discussion in 'Accidents and Near Misses' started by hank moon, Jul 5, 2013.

  1. hank moon

    hank moon lovely ligatures

    Messages:
    1,310
    Likes:
    1,513
    Date: July 5, 2013
    For Immediate Release
    Contacts:
    Zion Information Officer Aly Baltrus (435-703-3836)
    Kane County Sheriff Sgt. Alan Alldredge (435-644-4995)
    13-14

    Interagency SAR Team Responds to Two Accidents in the Same Canyon over Three Days

    Kanab, Utah- At 4:00 p.m. on Saturday, June 29, 2013, a multi-jurisdictional search and rescue was deployed in Kane County, just outside Zion National Park, after receiving a cell phone call that a 21 year old woman had fallen 40-60 feet in the Birch Hollow Slot Canyon. Kane County’s request for assistance was answered by Zion National Park (through a Mutual Aid Agreement with Kane County), a Ranger from the Bureau of Land Management, and Utah’s State Department of Natural Resources Park Manager.

    Kane County Sheriff Sgt. Alldredge and NPS Chief Ranger Purcell served as incident commanders for the Unified Command Rescue. Kane County mobilized their technical rope rescue team led by KSCO Volunteer King. Zion National Park responded with medics, a technical SAR team, and short haul rescue. The rescue was a success due to the resources and cooperation of all the agencies involved as well as their previous experience training together.

    BLM Ranger Alberts, also a KSCO SAR volunteer, was instrumental in leading the Interagency SAR team to the best location on the canyon rim to quickly access the patient. NPS Ranger Medic Fitzgerald and EMT Holthouse rappelled into the canyon, assessed and stabilized Ms. Moses, from Pocatello, ID. Suspecting a possible hip fracture and potentially significant internal injuries, the team quickly and efficiently secured her in a full body splint and litter and raised her 90 feet out of the deepest part of the slot. The remaining two members of the Moses party were also raised out of the canyon. Still not to the rim of the canyon, a tough 4th class climb through a heavily vegetated slope awaited the SAR evacuation team if a short haul rescue was not possible.

    The Interagency SAR team remained overnight with the stabilized patient. On Sunday, June 30, NPS Helicopter 7HL utilized a 250’ line for the short haul operation NPS Medic Fitzgerald and patient were lifted out of the canyon and delivered to a helispot north of the Zion Ponderosa, where a Life Flight Medical ship was standing by.

    The group, which consisted of five friends from Utah, Idaho and Colorado, had come to the area for a long weekend of canyoneering. They had already successfully completed Spry and Orderville Canyons inside Zion National Park. However, on their route through Birch Hollow, they experienced what all canyoneers need to be prepared for- something going wrong.

    The accident was caused by the incorrect use of a technique referred to as simul-rappelling with a non-experienced person on one side of the rope and Ms. Moses on the other counterbalancing each other’s weight. Simul-rappelling is considered an advanced skill by many in the canyoneering community. “She was still 40-60 feet from the bottom of the rappel when her tandem partner touched down and apparently let go,” said Chief Ranger Purcell. Kane County Sheriff’s Search and Rescue team reports “we saw this exact accident happen at the same rappel in Birch Hollow two years ago.”

    The canyoneering party admitted to the Rescuers that they were in the process of trying to pass another group in the canyon and that their attention was divided between the task at hand and their next move. They had also purposefully packed to be “light because they didn’t think anything bad would happen” according to Ranger Medic Fitzgerald. They were not well prepared when trouble struck. “Canyoneers need to have the ability to ascend ropes. They should carry extra food, headlamps, and a water purification system in case something goes wrong and they need to spend the night,” said Purcell. “It seemed this group relied on luck to be able to send someone to make a cell phone call and they were indeed lucky that they could get cell service. They were lucky too that the weather was not a factor in flying, and that the short-haul helicopter was available.”

    Late the next day, July 1st, Kane County Sgt. Alldredge received a telephone call reporting a second accident with injuries on the same rappel in Birch Hollow.

    A 21 year old female from Oregon, new to canyoneering and rappelling, had rappelled off the end of her rope and fallen 20-25 feet. Ms. Lindstrom-Demant and her partner apparently misjudged the length of the rappel. The victim was the first to descend, sustaining spinal and lower limb injuries. Luckily, a second canyoneering party was able to hike out and notify Kane County Dispatch. Kane County, Zion NP, and BLM and State Park Rangers reacted quickly and once again formed a Unified Command Rescue. The patient was accessed, stabilized, and raised out of the slot. NPS 7HL performed a second 250’ short haul with NPS Medic Thexton to an awaiting Life Flight Medical Ship in an amazing span of 6 ½ hours. Both of these incidents were successful because of the great working relationship of the numerous agencies involved.

    “Canyoneering and Rappelling have an inherent risk associated with them, “said Sgt. Alldredge. “When you add haste and inexperience, it can result in injury or even death. As the canyons of southern Utah and Zion National Park grow in popularity, we urge everyone to come prepared with the proper skills and equipment so their outings end successfully and without mishap.”
  2. Trevor

    Trevor

    Messages:
    9
    Likes:
    3
    Location:
    California
    Is simul-rapelling an oft-used technique in canyons? I've never done it, and never seen it used by any of the groups I've been with, even the faster ones.

    Seems needlessly risky when you can accomplish the same thing with a stone knot, for an additional 10 seconds of rigging time.
    Kuenn likes this.
  3. Erik B.

    Erik B. Thirsty for canyon...

    Messages:
    142
    Likes:
    212
    Location:
    Bellingham, Wa
    Stone knot for me...
  4. Mountaineer

    Mountaineer Is that an X slot?

    Messages:
    1,284
    Likes:
    986
    Not often, and mostly done as a stunt. There are situations it may make sense (such as an arch without other available anchor options - but maybe all of those you could argue as a stunt also). When done, there are techniques for added safety and to minimize rope grooves.
  5. Kuenn

    Kuenn

    Messages:
    1,364
    Likes:
    1,425
    Simul-rap a stunt? Maybe so, however any process if not done correctly has the potential for big-time failure, i.e. when simul-rapping you don't get off-rope until your partner is down....sheesh. I think we all experienced that object lesson in pre-school on the teeter totter during recess.

    X3 for the Stein knot.
    Amanda and JTMiller like this.
  6. Mountaineer

    Mountaineer Is that an X slot?

    Messages:
    1,284
    Likes:
    986
    Stone Knot, Double Figure 8 "bunny ears", Bowline on a Bight - isolating each strand for sure is best with a fixed anchor for simul-raps.

    My previous comment was intended as more narrow to those situations where there is no anchor other than meat (i.e. over an arch).
  7. Kuenn

    Kuenn

    Messages:
    1,364
    Likes:
    1,425
    I agree.

    I wasn't taking exception to any part of your previous comment, my point was that it doesn't matter what method you employ for abseiling if you don't do it correctly; as appeared to be the case based on the SAR report.
    Mountaineer likes this.
  8. Mike Zampino

    Mike Zampino Canyon season never ends.

    Messages:
    567
    Likes:
    541
    Location:
    Phoenix, AZ
    Let's not forget the simple precautions that can be taken to never ever rap off the end of a rope...even on a multi-staged rappel.
  9. Scott Patterson

    Scott Patterson

    Messages:
    1,090
    Likes:
    982
    I smell a future permit system.
  10. Stevee B

    Stevee B

    Messages:
    91
    Likes:
    73
    Mountaineer likes this.
  11. ratagonia

    ratagonia

    Messages:
    4,133
    Likes:
    4,967
    Location:
    Mount Carmel, Utah
Similar Threads: Multiple incidents
Forum Title Date
General Discussion Multiple shots fired at climbers in LCC Aug 29, 2017
General Discussion Multiple Tom Martin presentations in March-Phoenix Feb 3, 2015
Archives - Yahoo Canyons Group Pictures- Multiple Trips 12-28-10 Jan 5, 2011
Archives - Yahoo Canyons Group ~Policy: Multiple Personalities Sep 19, 2004
Archives - Yahoo Canyons Group what shirt and pants do you recommend for canyoneering in hot weather with multiple swims Sep 12, 2004
Archives - Yahoo Canyons Group Morning Report - multiple fires in Zion Jul 16, 2001