Hey, long time lurker but first time poster here. I’ve been canyoneering for a couple years but managing to get away with a small crappy bag, so I’m going for a new one. I’m considering buying an Imlay or Rodcle, but the price is convincing me to look elsewhere first. The two that stand out as canyon specific cheap bags are the BEAL Hydro Bag (https://www.canyonzone.com/a-47696709/canyon-packs/beal-hydro-bag/) at Moosejaw for $90 and the Edelrid Canyoneer Guide 50 (https://www.backcountry.com/edelrid-canyoneer-guide-50-backpack-3051cu-in )for $140-20% coupon. I’m thinking the Beal bag looks better, but having not had a canyon specific pack before I was wondering if anyone has experience with these or thoughts on the comparison between these and more expensive bags?